What is the Either-Or fallacy (False Dilemma)?
Identify the fallacy: 'You're either with us or against us.'
Which statement is a False Dilemma?
Hint: The fallacy leaves out reasonable middle options
Why is 'Either you agree with my plan or you do not care about the team' a False Dilemma?
Hint: Disagreement is not the only sign of not caring
What question helps test whether an argument is a False Dilemma?
Hint: False dilemmas hide other possibilities
Identify the fallacy: 'If we do not buy tablets for every class, students cannot learn.'
Hint: Learning may happen through more than one tool
How is a real either/or different from a False Dilemma?
Hint: The issue is whether the choices are exhaustive
Which revision removes the False Dilemma from 'Use this plan or quit the project'?
Hint: A good revision names additional reasonable choices